#RPGaDay2015 – Favorite Game You No Longer Play

RPG a day 2015 - Twitter

The game of my youth: AD&D 2nd Edition. By the time 3rd edition came out, I had a measure of system mastery, I could run it in my sleep, and I felt comfortable creating rules content for it that wasn’t unbalanced. I played 2nd edition for its entire life cycle, though I didn’t truly appreciate some of the settings (like Planescape and Spelljammer) until their time was long gone.

Of course, no game is truly dead as long as you still have the rules and can still play it. I play multiple, so-called “dead” games each year at Gary Con, but with the advent of 5th edition D&D, I doubt I’ll go back to 2nd edition AD&D for any reason. 5th edition captures the feel of AD&D for me, and if I was to run it at a convention, I would stick with 1st edition AD&D (though the two games are similar enough mechanically that new players wouldn’t even notice) because it’s what everyone thinks of when they think of the classic version (BECMI, B/X, or Rules Compendium D&D, aka “Basic” is fantastic, too; I would run that again before I run AD&D).

Categories: Random Thoughts | Tags: , , ,

Post navigation

One thought on “#RPGaDay2015 – Favorite Game You No Longer Play

  1. I did a whole blog post about that…
    But that having been said, Systems Failure (as one might have guessed) is the game that I miss the most. It captured my attention for many reasons, and was written wonderfully for having been a joke that became a serious setting book. But really, it becomes a question of obscurity and viability. You have to have a lot of clout to sell your players on a setting and premise, and if it falls flat, then you have to do a group brainstorm to see what everyone can agree on. It’s rather like trying to order a pizza by committee; you will eventually get something that everyone can agree on, but there are probably a lot of compromises. There are many other games that I would be happy to play even as a one shot, but as the years wax on, I find it harder and harder to petition for them.

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: